The Charleston Attack Was Terrorism

879 - Church
The Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church (Original photo by Cal Sr: Used under Creative Commons Attribution license.)

Less than 48 hours ago, a mass shooting took place at the historic  Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in downtown Charleston. Since then I have read many articles, Tweets, and statuses about this tragic attack. And, while there is still a lot we do not know1, we do know this much: this was a terrorist attack motivated by racism and white supremacist ideology. From the Wikipedia entry:

Dylann Storm Roof (born April 3, 1994) was named by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) as the suspected killer… One image on his Facebook page shows him in a jacket decorated with the flags of two former nations noted for their white supremacist policies, apartheid-era South Africa and Rhodesia… According to his roommate, Roof expressed his support of racial segregation in the United States and had intended to start a civil war…He also often claimed that “blacks were taking over the world”. Roof reportedly told neighbors of his plans to kill people, including a plot to attack the College of Charleston, but his claims were not taken seriously.

Before opening fire, Roof spent nearly an hour with the Bible study group. According to Gawker, “Roof told police he ‘almost didn’t’ kill nine people at Emanuel AME Church Wednesday night ‘because everyone was so nice’ to him,” but eventually he said “I have to do it. You rape our women and you’re taking over our country. And you have to go.” With that, he opened fire “while shouting racial epithets” on the 12 unarmed worshipers. He killed nine of them and intentionally left one survivor. Two others, one a five-year old child, survived by pretending to be dead. During the carnage, he reloaded five times.

Roof was caught yesterday morning after being tipped off by Debbie Dills, who is white. Dills spotted him on her way to work in North Carolina, called her boss (who called police), and then tailed Roof for another 35 miles until police arrived and arrested him. Roof waived his extradition rights and was brought back to South Carolina where conservative Republican governor Nikki Haley has called for prosecutors to pursue the death penalty. I mention the race of Dills and the politics of Haley for a simple reason: I am deeply saddened that many people, perhaps because they are accustomed to the terminology of Critical Race Theory2, seem to believe that the kind of white supremacy behind Roof’s actions is endemic within American society, or at least among white conservatives. It is not. I do not say this to defend political allies, but in the interests of bridging wounds.

I believe we are all in this together. I will not pretend for a moment that we all suffer from racism or sexism or other forms of intolerance and bigotry equally. Clearly we do not, and the long history of violent racial terrorism in the South–which is my home–should not be whitewashed or ignored. I do not believe that we should assume Roof was a lone wolf without first conducting an aggressive investigation to determine what group–if any–lent him material support or advocated his heinous course of action. Calls to take down the Confederate flag are legitimate. So are calls for white people–even those horrified by this action–to engage in some soul-searching about how we view white killers vs. black killers in the mainstream media.

I want to make it clear that in my view there is nothing ambiguous about who Roof is or what he has done. He is a monster who committed an atrocity. I am concerned that there are those who–in understandable shock and outrage, perhaps–believe that Roof has far more allies or sympathizers than he actually does 3. I am worried that an act like this–which, although the black community obviously bears the tragic cost directly–somehow will be seen as political when it is not. In addition to the personal tragedy faced by the victims and their families, this is a blow struck against the dream of equality and tolerance and understanding, and that is a dream that I believe can be shared (or sometimes neglected) by all Americans.

I pray for Roof to face justice, for his victims to be able to find some measure of peace, and also for us as a nation to find a way to draw closer together rather than farther apart.

2 thoughts on “The Charleston Attack Was Terrorism”

  1. Frankly, the left’s behavior is terrible. Jon Stewart recites standard liberal talking points, and is being hailed as a “prophet” and this is mostly being used as an excuse to tell conservative whites to shut up.

    The left has finally found the Great White Shooter they’ve been hoping for (I’m not exaggerating. Whenever there’s a mass shooting, lefty sites are always stating “I really hope this guy is white this time”).

    A few terrorists shoot up some people at a cartooning event, and we’re told we can’t draw any larger conclusions about anything except the organizers of the event were asking for it. However, this shooting allows them to draw all sorts of conclusions about how terrible white people (that aren’t liberal) are.

    A fried once told me the key to understanding the left is that they deeply, truly believe that society is always on the verge of falling back into the bad old days of Jim Crow and male supremacy. This event shows that to be true, based on the behavior I’m seeing on social media. Those on the right are saddened and mourn; those on the left are telling people to shut up and realize they have some blame in this event, due to their conservative whiteness (they’re also cussing – I’m seeing several liberal Mormons use the “f” word, but aimed at conservatives, not at the shooter).

  2. When it comes to political consequences, two things concern me on this one.

    The first is that the issue is so heavily politicized at all. It really shouldn’t be.

    The second is related, and it’s that each “side” is seeing the worst that the other has to offer. There are, as you point out, lots of liberals who have been waiting for an attack like this to justify their caricature of conservatives. That’s the worst of liberalism at this time.

    Then again, there are articles like this one from Deseret News about the shooting that are really kind of crazy. Here it is: In our opinion: Charleston church murders put racial hatred, attacks on worship in spotlight.

    The article is a ham-fisted attempt to capitalize off of this attack by interpreting it as an anti-religious act of secular terrorism. I don’t think there’s any validity to it, and it seems like a baseless and exploitative spin job. This piece gives some validity to liberal critique that conservatives refuse to take this event for what it was: an act of racist terrorism.

    It’s a tragic symbiosis, with each side hoping to see the worst in the other, and with some clueless or malign actors within each side obliging the other side in their wish.

Comments are closed.